2019

Cheslie Kryst

2018

Sarah Rose Summers

2017

Kara McCullough

2016

Deshauna Barber

2015

Olivia Jordan

2014

Nia Sanchez

2013

Erin Brady

2012

Olivia Culpo

Miss Universe Winner

2012

Nana Meriwether

2011

Alyssa Campanella

2010

Rima Fakih

2009

Kristen Dalton

2008- Crystle Stewart


2007- Rachel Smith


2006- Tara Conner


2005- Chelsea Cooley


2004- Shandi Finnessey


2003- Susie Castillo


2002- Shauntay Hinton


2001- Kandace Krueger


2000- Lynette Cole


1999- Kimberly Ann Pressler


1998- Shawnae Jebbia


1997- Brook Lee (Miss Universe Winner)


1997- Brandi Sherwood


1996- Ali Landry


1995- Chelsi Smith (Miss Universe Winner)


1995- Shanna Moakler


1995- Shanna Moakler


1994- Lu Parker


1993- Kenya Moore


1992- Shannon Marketic


1991- Kelli McCarty


1990- Carole Gist