2019
Cheslie Kryst
2018
Sarah Rose Summers
2017
Kara McCullough
2016
Deshauna Barber
2015
Olivia Jordan
2014
Nia Sanchez
2013
Erin Brady
2012
Olivia Culpo
Miss Universe Winner
2012
Nana Meriwether
2011
Alyssa Campanella
2010
Rima Fakih
2009
Kristen Dalton
2008- Crystle Stewart
2007- Rachel Smith
2006- Tara Conner
2005- Chelsea Cooley
2004- Shandi Finnessey
2003- Susie Castillo
2002- Shauntay Hinton
2001- Kandace Krueger
2000- Lynette Cole
1999- Kimberly Ann Pressler
1998- Shawnae Jebbia
1997- Brook Lee (Miss Universe Winner)
1997- Brandi Sherwood
1996- Ali Landry
1995- Chelsi Smith (Miss Universe Winner)
1995- Shanna Moakler
1995- Shanna Moakler
1994- Lu Parker
1993- Kenya Moore
1992- Shannon Marketic
1991- Kelli McCarty
1990- Carole Gist